{
  "at": "2026-09-16T04:30:04.619776+00:00",
  "status": "accepted-by-agent",
  "scope": "Same goPure Targ adaptation; measured gates plus blind reviews; no film/owner approval",
  "candidate": {
    "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/gopure-targ-uk-master.wav",
    "sha256": "81bf1b7930e3e930bd3155d1328c6f00780da6a92a65b4e0a034aea23e2e8865"
  },
  "gates": {
    "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/gates/master-cand-r5a1.gates.json",
    "sha256": "b914360dee2da8c7d0d491f3db1eef4cf9a1136378804454a532074884e5da7d"
  },
  "adjudications": [
    {
      "claim": "Sustained notes (11) and held non-focus words (14) exceed the targets derived from Targ.",
      "disposition": "accepted-observation",
      "reason": "Measured on the candidate's stems and ASR clocks. The full-voice directions that restored a sung coda also brought more sustain than the speech-shaped round-3 take (6/9); both values still improve on version 1 (20 and about 30). Disclosed as open rows; not blocking because the singing requirement outranks the sustain target.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/whole-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "55482c4d27433779ad6c8a154d30fdf238ba1a08668b32f2e6e87ec7b243c156"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "Care block sings at 3.91 syl/s against the 3.6 target.",
      "disposition": "accepted-observation",
      "reason": "Consistent across all sixteen takes (3.5–3.9); a property of the 66-syllable block as the provider paces it. Disclosed; a text trim is the lever for a future pass.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/whole-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "55482c4d27433779ad6c8a154d30fdf238ba1a08668b32f2e6e87ec7b243c156"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "The candidate is sung throughout: no recited passages; the coda is fully pitched and contains every order condition; brand heard as GoPure.",
      "disposition": "accepted-observation",
      "reason": "Blind whole review (source + this candidate + the round-4 candidate) returns verdict \"sung\" with an empty recitedPassages list; per-phrase pitch medians on the master corroborate (coda phrases 57–60 MIDI). This resolves the defect that rejected the round-3 and round-4 candidates.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/whole-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "55482c4d27433779ad6c8a154d30fdf238ba1a08668b32f2e6e87ec7b243c156"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p3-return-coda-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "2a537afa3bb06ef4dd702d4978b470c51ca019550b379fd6be4f510a1a1d1331"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "Attachments 2 and 3 of the whole review are the same master.",
      "disposition": "rejected-observation",
      "reason": "They are different takes (r5a_1 and r4a_1) with different durations (197.1 s and 192.3 s) and hashes; the reviewer conflated similar performances of the same lyrics on the same seed. Its per-attachment observations are kept; the identity claim is not.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/whole-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "55482c4d27433779ad6c8a154d30fdf238ba1a08668b32f2e6e87ec7b243c156"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "The band does not perform a tacet stop on «Стій».",
      "disposition": "rejected-observation",
      "reason": "Stem measurement on the master at 93.48 s: music level falls to -34.4 dB (min) and -13.5 dB (median over 1.4 s) relative to the preceding 8 s — a clear band drop, above the 12 dB threshold of the P1 stop row. The scene reviewer's 'continuous rhythm' is contradicted by the stems; the whole-song reviewer heard the freeze.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p1-mentor-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "8820987391e4adf24b429a71a5eabf3d96586ef5e1546cd68e2a06a52a669502"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/whole-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "55482c4d27433779ad6c8a154d30fdf238ba1a08668b32f2e6e87ec7b243c156"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "The question «Чим ти користуєшся?» lacks the source's melisma and the compliment line is absent; the laugh is narrated; Larysa's counter-question is sung straight without a sassy spoken persona.",
      "disposition": "accepted-observation",
      "reason": "Delivery gaps against the source mechanisms; the compliment line was not in the adapted text (version 1 also omitted it) and the singing-throughout requirement deliberately trades the spoken persona for pitched delivery. Recorded as remaining gaps, not word or meaning defects.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p1-mentor-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "8820987391e4adf24b429a71a5eabf3d96586ef5e1546cd68e2a06a52a669502"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "The punchline «All of that is making it worse» is replaced by daily-care advice.",
      "disposition": "rejected-observation",
      "reason": "Adaptation decision from version 1 and the advertorial: no claim that every former product harmed the neck (claim limits); the advice is the pivot that motivates consistent care.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p1-mentor-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "8820987391e4adf24b429a71a5eabf3d96586ef5e1546cd68e2a06a52a669502"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "«якась» crowds the cadence before the week-six jump; no breath or thinning before «А за шість»; «не повірила очам» sung legato rather than as a surprise attack.",
      "disposition": "accepted-observation",
      "reason": "Consistent with the plan's thin event not being realised by the provider; minor per the reviewer. Kept as remaining gaps for a future pass.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p2-results-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "3b619af06e782c673c448e989b060c0c5e5ac48468dd31692305915e137da2b5"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "The daughter's colour, the understated payoff «вийшла на люди», the delayed «до речі», the peak on «свою я», the air before the brand and the brand diction are matched.",
      "disposition": "accepted-observation",
      "reason": "Scene reviews mark these mechanisms matched; measured air before the brand 2.3 s; brand line ASR-uncertain as in every take but heard clearly by two blind reviewers.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p2-results-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "3b619af06e782c673c448e989b060c0c5e5ac48468dd31692305915e137da2b5"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p3-return-coda-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "2a537afa3bb06ef4dd702d4978b470c51ca019550b379fd6be4f510a1a1d1331"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "Second-gaze negations are legato rather than staccato.",
      "disposition": "accepted-observation",
      "reason": "Consistent across all candidates; a delivery gap against the source, not a text defect.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p3-return-coda-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "2a537afa3bb06ef4dd702d4978b470c51ca019550b379fd6be4f510a1a1d1331"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "A stray vocal fragment precedes the closing excerpt.",
      "disposition": "rejected-observation",
      "reason": "Excerpt boundary artefact: the scene pair starts 0.3 s before «У червні» inside continuous singing; the full master has no such fragment.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p3-return-coda-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "2a537afa3bb06ef4dd702d4978b470c51ca019550b379fd6be4f510a1a1d1331"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p2-results-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "3b619af06e782c673c448e989b060c0c5e5ac48468dd31692305915e137da2b5"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    },
    {
      "claim": "The coda is denser than the source's two-fact outro.",
      "disposition": "rejected-observation",
      "reason": "All ordering conditions stay sung by owner authority (informationBudget); coda rate 3.34 syl/s is a P1 row and follows 2.3 s of air.",
      "evidence": [
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/reviews/p3-return-coda-r5a1-v01/evaluation.json",
          "sha256": "2a537afa3bb06ef4dd702d4978b470c51ca019550b379fd6be4f510a1a1d1331"
        },
        {
          "path": "/workspaces/UGS/AdFactorySongFormat/trees/c06fb16085/runs/targ-ten-c06fb16085-v01/song/master-candidates/cand-r5a1/provenance.json",
          "sha256": "fd87ce5b69f4e94811005642278cfba5ae16fd7f9fc3bfb53e65ba47321d2989"
        }
      ],
      "blocking": false
    }
  ],
  "decision": "Accept candidate cand-r5a1 (same-take remix of Suno V6 cover take r5a_1, all directions full-voice sung, coda in mid register) as the version 2 musical master. Measured on the master: 9/17 gate rows; passes register spread 11.8 st (Targ 12.0), speech-register share 19% (Targ 16%), vocal +0.7 dB over the band in the worst block (Targ −1.0), centroid 3793 Hz (Targ 3853), LRA 4.3 (Targ 4.3), care block 16.9 s (Targ 14.6), 2.3 s of air before the brand (Targ 2.3), falling endings 33% (Targ 39%), 197.1 s; the four coda phrases and the product list carry pitch (medians 57–60), unlike the round-3 and round-4 candidates. Open rows: 11 sustained notes (target 10, Targ 8; version 1 had 20), 14 held non-focus words (target 10, Targ 9; version 1 about 30), care density 3.91 syl/s (target 3.6; version 1 4.07), plus P1 rows (coda rate 3.34 vs 3.2, four instrumental gaps, rate variance 0.25, thirds 16.5%). 58/59 lines matched by ASR (the brand line is ASR-uncertain in every take). Blind reviews: the whole-song reviewer returns \"sung\" with no recited passages and names this candidate closest to the source; scene reviews match the daughter colour, the understated payoff, the delayed до речі, the peak on свою, the air before the brand and the brand diction, and record the remaining gaps (no tacet on Стій, no melisma on the question, legato negations, no breath before шість). No score is assigned; the owner's rating is not claimed.",
  "limitations": [
    "All listening is model-mediated; no claim of continuous human listening or owner approval.",
    "Gate values are estimates on Demucs stems and ASR clocks; they screen candidates and do not grade art.",
    "The master is a same-take remix (per-block vocal lift, presence shelf, one bar of music-only bed inserted before the brand, compressor, loudness normalisation); separated-stem processing can add artefacts that only listening can weigh.",
    "One synthetic voice performs all roles; character colour is intonation and register, not separate singers.",
    "The 3/6-week storyline is dramatization, not guaranteed product efficacy."
  ],
  "unresolvedBlocking": []
}